Editor’s Note: This story is originally from September 2018
Over the decades, education curriculums have changed quite a bit. People might even argue that some have been watered down.
But when it comes to giving students grades, should they be given a free pass when the work hasn’t been done?
Giving zeroes to students landed one teacher in hot water
A former teacher of 17 years in Port St. Lucie, Florida doesn’t believe so – a belief that got her fired when she refused to give students a 50% credit for work her students did not complete.
In 2018, Diane Tirado was a 52-year-old educator who was teaching Social Studies to eighth-graders at West Gate K-8 School. During the school year, she assigned her students an explorer’s notebook project with two weeks to complete it.
However, when some of her students failed to turn in the assignment, she was led to give them a mark of zero.
“If there’s nothing to grade,” Tirado said, “how can I give somebody a 50%?” (1)
That’s when a strange and confusing policy was brought to her attention. In the West Gate student and parent handbook, there is a No Zero policy below the grading outline highlighted in red: “NO ZERO’s – LOWEST POSSIBLE GRADE IS 50%.”
Upon hearing from school administrators that you simply give them a 50 even if they don’t turn anything, Tirado refused saying, “Oh, we don’t. This is not kosher.” (1)
Fired and Fired Up
On September 14, 2018, Tirado was terminated. Before leaving, however, she left a goodbye note for her students on a whiteboard as she wouldn’t be able to do it in person.
Mrs. Tirado loves you and wishes you the best in life! I have been fired for refusing to give you a 50% for not handing anything in.
[heart] Mrs. Tirado”
Since being fired, Tirado has called for the school to revisit this “no zero” policy. She believes that this level of spoon-feeding will not help students in the long-run.
“I’m arguing the fact that you don’t get something for nothing. I want the policy change, and it’s not just here,” she told CBS 12. (1)
“I’m so upset because we have a nation of kids that are expecting to get paid and live their life just for showing,” she told WPTV. “And it’s not real.” (2)
Interestingly, Kerry Padrick, the chief information officer for the school district, said there is no policy stopping teachers from giving students a grade of zero.
“The District’s Uniform Grading System utilizes letter grades A-F, numerical grades 100-0 and grade point average from 4-0,” Padrick said in a statement. “Some classroom teachers and school faculties have discussed the range of points for work submitted in each grading category.” (2)
This clearly contradicts the apparent reasons for which Tirado was fired. And to complicate matters, West Gate’s handbook even indicates that a letter grade of “I” (incomplete) is equivalent to 0.
Whether any changes to the policy will be made, time will have to tell. One thing will not change, at least for this teacher: “A grade in Mrs. Tirado’s class is earned.”
What do you think? Is this still an issue? Have any of our readers encountered this in the children’s schools? Let us know in the comments.
Read More: 8-year-old holds hand of crying classmate with autism so he feels less scared on first day of school
- “Teacher says she was fired for giving zeroes to students who didn’t turn in their work.” CBS 12. Luli Ortiz. September 24, 2018.
- “A Florida teacher says she was fired because she didn’t give credit to students who didn’t do work.” WPTV. Amy Lipman. September 24, 2018.
This article was originally published on Secret Life of Mom in May 2021 and has been republished here with permission.